Rebuttal to “The right government for America” Given the left-leaning political tendencies of college students and professors, this paper’s courting of more conservative views might be refreshing if they weren’t some of the whiniest, most argumentatively weak op-eds I’ve ever read. “The right government for America” by Curtis Kalin in the Oct. 18 issue of Broadside seems to be the latest in a series of articles (the others by Moore and Minster) complaining about the liberal tendencies of academia. The articles lack any real point or purpose, other than for their authors to cry and grieve to each other over their perceived subjection to cognitive dissonance by people with whom they disagree. I found three glaring problems with this particular creed. First, his summation of liberal ideology is nothing but a straw man built from seriously dubious generalizations. I haven’t heard many liberals argue for a “small intellectual elite” to rule over the dumb masses (which seems more descriptive of classical conservatism, anyway), yet we’re supposed to accept those points as the “pervasive assumptions among liberal academia” without even knowing which professors actually said any of those things? Secondly, his straw man actually has a point. Americans’ lack of civic […]
Comments